What information can Minnesotans who get their electricity from a rural electric cooperative find on their co-op’s website? For example, can co-op members get a basic explanation about the charges and fees on their electric bill? Can they see what mix of energy sources their electricity comes from? Is there information on how to vote in co-op elections, attend a board meeting or contact a board member?
Access to this kind of information is especially important at electric co-ops because co-ops are owned by the residents and businesses they serve. Electric co-ops, according to their guiding cooperative principles, should be democratic organizations in which elected directors are accountable to co-op members and the co-op provides information and education to enable members to be active participants and contributors.
The internet isn’t the only way to get information of course, but it’s certainly an expected go-to nowadays. So to get a gauge on how Minnesota’s electric co-ops are doing on providing information members need to understand co-op policies and participate in the organizations they own, we started with a look at co-op websites. We reviewed the sites of all 44 rural electric cooperatives in Minnesota – which combined serve about 1.7 million people across nearly every part of the state – and looked for nine basic pieces of information. The research is current as of October 29, 2018.
The results show significant cause for concern about the current state of co-op websites when it comes to the kind of transparency and information needed to foster democracy – and we hope the findings provide inspiration for improvement. Websites at the vast majority (86%) of co-ops in the state are missing information on more than half the topics we reviewed. Half of Minnesota’s co-ops (50%) are missing information for at least seven or more of the nine topics. There were no perfect scores.
The information we looked for and what we found (or didn’t)
Below we provide a full rundown of the information we looked for, the findings (% yes the website included the item, % no it did not), and a brief explanation of the topic and why we prioritized it. Topics fall into two categories: information about co-op policies and information about how members can participate or provide input.
Information about co-op policies
- Electric bill explanation (48% yes, 52% no). Electric bills can be complicated, with jargon and fine print. Being transparent with co-op members about their bills, like this co-op web page that explains the different charges and fees, is a key precursor to enabling co-op members to evaluate and participate in decisions around this core aspect of their co-op’s business.
- Energy source mix (100% no). Should co-op members be able to provide input on what mix of energy sources their electric bills are paying for? To do so, members need information on their co-op’s energy portfolio, like this one provided by Xcel Energy for its customers. Although local co-ops in Minnesota are “distribution” rather than “generation” electric cooperatives, it’s their local co-op that residents look to for information—so we hoped to find local co-ops featuring this through an easy-to-find page or link. Unfortunately, we couldn’t find any co-op that included this information on their website.
- Co-op bylaws (66% yes, 34% no). Bylaws for a co-op are the rules for governance, membership and operations, so is an obvious document member-owners need to be able to access. We expected this to be the most commonly posted item, and indeed it’s the only one of the nine that can be found on a majority of co-op websites in Minnesota. The fact that nearly a third of the 44 co-ops in the state don’t post their bylaws online is surprising, and concerning.
- Board meeting minutes/notes (34% yes, 66% no). Significant policy discussions and decisions often take place at co-op board meetings, so ensuring members can easily find out what happens at each meeting is important to democratic control. Here’s one example of a common way co-ops post board meeting summaries, and we also counted a “yes” even for co-ops whose sites were out of date on posting board notes but at least had some uploaded. Most co-ops, even when they did post notes, only included them in their newsletter archives.
- Manager/director salaries (2% yes, 98% no). Compensation for leaders is another part of co-op policy that members can have a say in. As nonprofits, cooperatives report the compensation of their directors and key employees each year on IRS Form 990s, which are public. In the interests of transparency and member education, co-ops could make it easy on their members to find this information by posting their 990s or leadership compensation information on their websites — rather than keeping it off and expecting members to search internet databases on their own. We found one co-op in Minnesota out of 44 that links to its 990 at the bottom of its website’s “About” page.
Information about how members can participate, or provide input
- How to vote in co-op elections (20% yes, 80% no). This one doesn’t need much explanation as to why it matters for democratic control. While co-op bylaws may contain information on voting, we expected co-ops would want to separately, prominently and permanently highlight voting information on their websites rather than expecting members to hunt for it in dense bylaws or other documents – so that’s what we looked for. Only nine co-op sites out of 44 featured information on how voting is done, often via an FAQ section like this example. However, many of the co-ops we listed as “yes” only included this information in their newsletter archive.
- How to run for co-op board (39% yes, 61% no). Running for a seat on a co-op board of directors can be intimidating for a co-op member who’s never run before, and one way to encourage this aspect of co-op democracy is to be open and upfront on the co-op website about running for office. This is another area where co-ops that do provide some information often do so through an FAQ section or listing it in the newsletter archive.
- Board meeting dates (34% yes, 66% no). Inviting members to attend board meetings – providing them with advance notice of meeting dates, times, locations and agendas – is key to facilitating member input in decision-making. For our report card we looked to see if co-op websites at least provided upcoming board meeting dates; while Connexus Energy provided a great example for other co-ops to follow, many other co-ops included this information only in their newsletter archive.
- Board member contact information (25% yes, 75% no). Last, but not certainly not least, we reviewed websites for whether co-ops provide either phone numbers or email addresses for members to be able to contact their elected representatives – certainly another important way to facilitate member input. This turns out to be another pretty basic and simple area of improvement needed at about two-thirds of electric co-ops in our state.
For more information about our review of rural electric co-op websites in Minnesota, or to let us know if your co-op has already taken steps to address areas of concern identified in the report card, please contact us at . To learn more about how you advocate for improvements to your co-op’s website, click here or send us an ">email.
CURE’s Minnesota Local Energy Project produced the Minnesota Rural Electric Co-op Report Card because we want co-op member-owners to have access to more and better information about the rural electric co-op they co-own. The information collected from rural electric co-op websites was last updated on October 29, 2018, and was accurate as of that date. The use of names, likenesses, trademarks, and wordmarks included in the Report Card and on the Minnesota Local Energy Project website are intended solely for purposes of non-commercial expression to further the public interest through criticism, commentary, and news reporting.